Book of Sothis

The Book of Sothis is a document known mainly by transmission by George Syncellus[1] (died after AD 810), purporting to have been written by the historian Manethon (who lived during the early 3rd century BCE).[2] Modern scholars are nearly unanimous that the book was in fact written by someone other than Manethon, considering it a forgery written before the fifth century. Its contents are consequently regarded as being of little value to Egyptology, although a classic of pseudepigraphy.[3]

While the unknown author is considered to have displayed a thorough knowledge of Manethon, the best indication of forgery is the introductory dedication to Ptolemy II Philadelphus, referring to him as "σεβαστῷ" (sebastōi) — i.e. "august" or Augustus, a Roman title that was not used until centuries after Manethon's death.

However, since the original text hasn't been found, all claims of pseudepigraphy rely on the assumption that Syncellus' transcription of the text was equal to the original text, ruling out that he might have gotten an adapted version or that he might have paraphrased himself. Indeed, the main argument against it seems to be its controversial content, with the purported inconsistencies being merely auxiliary to the argument.[2]

Syncellus states that Manethon included information from monuments in "the Siriadic land" (variously conjectured to be Assyria, Arabia or Egypt), that had been engraved before the Deluge, but afterward had been translated and stored in hieroglyphic books in Egyptian temples.

References
  1. Ecloga Chronographica 73.14
  2. Gerald Verbrugghe; John Wickersham (19 January 2001). Berossos and Manetho, Introduced and Translated: Native Traditions in Ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt. University of Michigan Press. pp. 177–. ISBN 978-0-472-08687-0. Retrieved 16 October 2012.
  3. Adler, W., Berossus, Manetho, and 1 Enoch in the World Chronicle of Panodorus, The Harvard Theological Review, 1983 - Cambridge Univ Press.


This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.