Bilal Abdul Kareem
Bilal Abdul Kareem (born Darrell Lamont Phelps) is an American journalist and war correspondent covering the Syrian Civil War[1][2] who has worked with CNN[3]. He believes that he has been placed on the US kill list.[4] He claims to have survived five drone assassination attempts by the US military, which killed random civilians that were present nearby, including two attacks on vehicles he was traveling in, including one where the car he was sitting in was blown up by a missile shot from a drone.[5][6]
Bilal Abdul Kareem | |
|---|---|
Darrell Lamont Phelps | |
| Born | Darrell Lamont Phelps |
| Nationality | American |
| Citizenship | United States |
| Occupation | Journalist and war correspondent |
| Employer | CNN, OGN (On the Ground News) TV |
| Known for | For Syrian Civil War journalism and allegedly being put in American Disposition Matrix |
He has been criticized by some observers for a perceived alignment with jihadi fighters in Syria, with The New York Times reporting that Kareem was considered a "jihadist propagandist" to some.[1] RT criticized his reported "praise" of Malhama Tactical, a 'private military contractor' which trains militant groups.[7]
Early life and career
Abdul Kareem, born Darrell Lamont Phelps, grew up in Mount Vernon, New York; he attended Mount Vernon High School,[1] then studied creative writing[8] at Purchase College SUNY, before going on to work in stand-up comedy.[9] He converted to Islam, partly due to its "emphasis on clean living",[1] travelled to Egypt to study Arabic, where he later obtained a presenting role with Saudi- funded television channel, Huda TV. After leaving Huda TV, due to "disagreements", he travelled to Rwanda and Libya to film documentaries,[10] before arriving in Syria in 2012 where he was first hosted by Ahrar al-Sham.[8]
After initially working with Western mainstream news outlets, such as Sky News and the BBC,[10] he helped found "On The Ground News". Publishing on Facebook, Twitter and YouTube,[1] its official website claims it is "committed to delivering accurate English language news to a Western audience regarding the Syrian crisis".[11]
He's married with five children.[1]
On 13 August 2020, it was reported that Abdul Kareem had been arrested by Hay'at Tahrir al-Sham in Atme, northern Idlib.[12]
Court case, initial refusal to dismiss
In 2017, he filed a lawsuit against the United States government in the District of Columbia, claiming they had attempted to assassinate him, and requesting his removal from the Disposition Matrix, usually referred to as the "kill list".[13] Another journalist, Ahmad Muaffaq Zaidan, who is suspected of also being placed on the American kill list, co-sued with him.[9][14] In June 2018, government lawyers asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit claiming Bilal could not provide proof he was being targeted as he could not substantiate his claims given the secrecy surrounding targeting decisions and that the government had complete authority in military operations outside of the United States. US District Judge Rosemary Collyer rejected the government request to dismiss the lawsuit and in the opinion paper wrote: “Due process is not merely an old and dusty procedural obligation. . . . It is a living, breathing concept that protects US persons from overreaching government action even, perhaps, on an occasion of war.” The judge also ruled that Bilal cannot challenge the laws that allows the US government to put someone on the "kill list" or target those on it, but as an American citizen he has the right to due process before being added and to know whether his speech as a reporter is protected by the first amendment or not, as the reason Bilal claims he is on the list is because of his speech.[15]
The judge also distinguished the case from previous killings of US citizens such as the drone strike that killed Anwar al-Awlaki, stating that Bilal is not challenging the "kill list" program or military operations but is challenging the process that places a citizen on the list without notice or a challenge.[15]
The judge also dismissed Ahmad Muaffaq Zaidan from the lawsuit as his claims that he is a target were speculative. Ahmad is not a US citizen.[15]
Subsequent near misses
In May 2019, he survived being shelled by a Syrian Army tank in Idlib but was wounded by shrapnel. He was with Sky News reporters during the attack.[16]
In July 2019, Bilal and his crew survived nearby shelling by a jet's autocannon on the Hama frontline.[17]
Dismissal of court case
The government filed a subsequent motion to dismiss arguing that the case could not go forward because the relief sought by Kareem (information about whether he was on the kill list, presentation of the evidence that was used to put him there, a description of the process that was used to put him there, and removal from the list) along with any evidence that might be used in the case were all protected by the state secrets privilege. The court sided with the government and dismissed the case, leaving Kareem without any recourse:
"Without access to the privileged information, Mr. Kareem is unable to establish whether he has targeted by the lethal force or what information was considered in reaching the alleged decision to target him. Mr. Kareem is "incapable of demonstrating that [he has] sustained a violation of" his constitutional rights without the information ... He 'has alleged, but ultimately cannot show, a concrete injury amounting to either a specific present objective harm or a threat of specific future harm. in this instance, in which the relevant information is solely in the control of the United States and is protected by the state secrets privilege, Mr. Kareem is left with no method to obtain it to pursue his case, which must therefore be dismissed.[18]
References
- Hubbard, Ben (March 10, 2017). "Reporting From Syria, an American With a Point of View and a Message". The New York Times. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- Stafford Smith, Clive (December 19, 2016). "Reporting from the ground in times of war". Al Jazeera. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- Ward, Clarissa (March 14, 2016). "#UndercoverInSyria: Clarissa Ward reports from behind rebel lines". CNN. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- Friedersdorf, Conor (June 18, 2018). "The American Who Says He's Been the Target of Five Air Strikes". The Atlantic. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- "How an American Citizen Ended Up on the US Kill List | Rolling Stone – YouTube".
- Khan, Zain (July 9, 2018). "Bilal Abdul Kareem : Who Escaped 5 US Drone Strike and Is on a US Kill List". The Siasat Daily. Retrieved November 2, 2018.
- "Media darling 'Aleppo survivor' praises jihadi mercenaries training anti-Assad rebels". RT. August 7, 2018. Retrieved November 15, 2018.
- "Bilal Abdul Kareem - Life with the Syrian rebels". 5Pillars. July 16, 2014.
- Taibbi, Matt (July 19, 2018). "How to Survive America's Kill List". Rolling Stone. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- "Bilal Abdul Kareem Journalist". bilalabdulkareem.com.
- "On The Ground News". ogn.news. December 21, 2019.
- "Journalist Bilal Abdul Kareem arrested by HTS in Syria's Idlib". Middle East Eye. August 13, 2020.
- "Due Process and Surviving America's Kill List: How the Courts and Congress Can End the Executive Branch's Encroachment on Civil Liberties in the War on Terror by Pj Novack :: SSRN". SSRN 3369310. Cite journal requires
|journal=(help) - Hooper, Simon; Thomas-Johnson, Amandla (March 31, 2017). "Journalist Bilal Abdul Kareem files lawsuit over alleged US 'kill list'". Middle East Eye. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- Hsu, Spencer (June 13, 2018). "Judge allows journalist to challenge claimed inclusion on U.S. drone 'kill list'". The Washington Post.
- Crawford, Alex (May 24, 2019). "Syria: Sky News witnesses horrors of Syria's last rebel outpost". Sky News. Retrieved June 12, 2019.
- "What Filming with Bilal Abdul Kareem is Really Like – YouTube".
- "Kareem v. Haspel | Civil Action No. 17-581 (RMC) | D.D.C. | Judgment | Law | CaseMine". www.casemine.com. Retrieved January 29, 2020.