Ann Bilansky

Ann Bilansky (born Mary Ann Evards Wright) (c. 1820 – March 23, 1860) was an American housewife convicted in 1859 of poisoning her husband with arsenic.[1][2] She is the only woman in Minnesota to receive the death penalty and the first white person in the state to be executed by hanging.[3][4][5]

Ann Bilansky
Born
Mary Ann Evards Wright

c. 1820
Fayetteville, North Carolina
DiedMarch 23, 1860
Saint Paul, Minnesota
OccupationHousewife
Criminal statusExecuted by Hanging
Spouse(s)Stanislaus Bilansky
Conviction(s)Murder
Criminal penaltyDeath

Biography

Mary Ann Evards Wright (known by her middle name, Ann) was born in Fayetteville, North Carolina, where she resided for several years with her first husband who later died in a railroad incident. She then moved to Pleasant Hill, Illinois, and then finally to St. Paul, Minnesota in April 1858 at the request of her nephew, John Walker, who was ill with typhoid fever.[6] Shortly after, Ann married Stanislaus Bilansky, one of the first Polish immigrants to settle in St. Paul. He had he moved to St. Paul from Wisconsin in 1848.[7][8] Stanislaus was a poor man who drank a lot, but he owned a small cabin that doubled as a bar and grocery store.[9] He had custody of his three young children left in his care after his second wife divorced him, and Ann frequently took care of the children when Stanislaus was ill or working.[10] In 1859, Stanislaus was sick between March 6 and March 11 with what was thought to be indigestion, but his condition worsened rapidly with the consumption of alcohol and Graffenburg pills. Ann was seen crying at his bedside asking what she should do with kids in case anything happened. Stanislaus died on March 11.[10]

The trial

As the funeral procession was leaving the Bilansky residence to bury Stanislaus at the cemetery, officials from the Ramsey County coroner's office arrived to conduct an inquest.[10] A doctor examined the body and a coroner's jury was assembled to hear testimony from John Walker, a visiting neighbor named Lucinda Kilpatrick, and a housekeeper hired during Stanislaus’ illness named Roasa Scharf. The coroner's jury found that Stanislaus died of natural causes, but questioned why Ann had not called a doctor toward the end of his illness.[11] Stanislaus was then buried on March 12, but that evening Kilpatrick changed her testimony to claim she saw Ann buying arsenic from a drugstore on February 28. Ann claimed the purchase was at Stanislaus’ urging, so they might kill rats in the cellar.[11] After taking Kilpatrick's new testimony, Stanislaus’ body was exhumed for an examination and on March 13, Ann was arrested for the murder of her husband.[11]

A second coroner's jury convened to hear testimonies from Scharf and Kilpatrick, as well as from druggist W.H. Wolff and Dr. J.D. Goodrich. Wolff testified that a single crystal was found under a microscope that “resembled arsenic,” but Goodrich was skeptical that Stanislaus was poisoned.[11] The jury concluded that Stanislaus died of arsenic poisoning, a grand jury indicted Ann for the murder of her husband and a trial date was set for May 23.[11]

The trial was conducted at the Ramsey County courthouse, and the prosecution, led by Isaac Heard, included three main arguments in their case against Ann: she had purchased arsenic and had the means to kill, she had inappropriate relations with Walker and therefore an affair gave her the motive for murder, and she had made comments that suggested she was contemplating murder.[12] Kilpatrick was the state's principal witness, and Heard also relied heavily on Scharf's testimony, which stated that Ann made all of Stanislaus’ meals separately and did not treat him as a husband ought to be treated. Both Kilpatrick and Scharf claimed Ann was having an affair with Walker in an attempt to provide a murder motive.[13] After all of the witnesses had spoken, an all-male jury began deliberations on June 3, and they took less than six hours to return with a “guilty” verdict.[14] Upon hearing the verdict, Ann reportedly showed no visible signs of emotion or distress.[15] Ann's defense asked for a new trial, but did not receive one as the judge considered her already found guilty in the court. The case went to the Minnesota Supreme Court to try and dispute the death penalty, but that court also did not see the need for a new trial and sent Ann for sentencing.[14] Ann briefly escaped prison on July 25. She hid in the Lake Como area and eventually made contact with Walker, but was found on August 1.[16]

Sentencing

On December 2, Ann appeared in court for her sentencing where she proclaimed herself an innocent woman: “If I die in this case, I die an innocent woman. I don’t think I have had a fair and just trial.[16] She was sentenced to one month in solitary confinement followed by death by hanging. Governor Henry Sibley had the legal responsibility of setting the execution date, but he refused to set a date or commute the sentence, and he let his term expire at the end of 1859.[17] The Minnesota House of Representatives made efforts to end capital punishment, but it was rejected shortly after.[17] On January 18, 1860 another bill was introduced to prohibit the execution of women but was tabled.[18] On January 25, 1860 newly elected Governor Alexander Ramsey set Ann’s execution date as March 23, 1860.[12] Another bill was passed by the state legislature on March 5 to try and help Ann, which stated that the first execution by Minnesota should not be that of a woman and that Ann had an unfair trial, but this was vetoed by Governor Ramsey on March 8.[19]

Execution

Ann requested a private execution, but at this point in the 19th century public executions were typical as they served civil and religious purposes to deter crime and demonstrate the danger of sin.[20] On March 23, 1860, gallows were set up in an enclosure in Court House Square at the corner of Fifth and Cedar streets, and just before her execution Ann spoke her last words: “I die without having had any mercy shown me, or justice. I die for the good of my soul, and not for murder. . . . Your courts of justice are not courts of justice—but I will yet get justice in Heaven.”[6] Around 100 onlookers watched from inside the enclosure, while thousands more watched from outside the enclosure.[21] Ann's body was left hanging for twenty minutes before she was buried in an unmarked grave in Calvary Cemetery.[5][21]

Reaction from the press

Throughout Ann's entire trial and execution, the St. Paul Pioneer and Democrat focused heavily on her gender. She was heavily criticized for her “lack of marital virtue,” and at times the press was more focused on her failure as a wife than on her moral failure of committing murder.[22] The Democrat also criticized other women for their eagerness to watch the execution.[23] The day after the execution, the Democrat grew tired of the story, stating that it hoped to never have to report about Bilansky or the execution ever again.[24]

Ann Bilansky's trial and execution was the basis for Jeffrey Hatcher's stage play, A Piece of Rope, which premiered in St. Paul in March 2000.[25]

gollark: Cut it into tenths and give 7/10 to someone else.
gollark: Obviously, if you unhide it, the GoN inspectors *may* do a random test and fine you. In that case you may need to bribe them.
gollark: If you hide your scroll, the GoN inspectors can't see it, so you can summon any amount!
gollark: I want a million leetle trees.
gollark: They won't, don't worry.

References
  1. Farber, Zac (28 February 2017). "Politics of the Past: 'Grave doubts' couldn't stop hanging". Minnesota Lawyer. Bridgetower Media. Archived from the original on 5 October 2017. Retrieved 2 June 2018.
  2. Cecil, Matthew (1997). "Justice in Heaven: The Trial of Ann Bilansky". Minnesota History. 55: 350–363.
  3. "1860: Ann Bilansky". ExecutedToday.com. ExecutedToday.com. 23 March 2014. Archived from the original on 13 May 2018. Retrieved 2 June 2018.
  4. Ragsdale, Jim (23 March 2000). "Minnesota's first execution still a tantalizing tale". Twin Cities. Digital First Media. Archived from the original on 2 June 2018. Retrieved 2 June 2018.
  5. Nelson, Paul (April 28, 2014). "Execution of Ann Bilansky". MNopedia.
  6. Cecil 1997, p. 350-351
  7. Radzilowski, John (Autumn 2006). “Wojciechowo: Polish Immigrants in St. Paul, Minnesota, 1875 to 1925”. Polish American Studies. 63: 23-57.
  8. Shipman, Marlin (2002). The Penalty is Death: U.S. Newspaper Coverage of Women’s Executions. Columbia: University of Missouri Press. p. 258.
  9. Bessler, John D. (2003). Legacy of Violence: Lynch Mobs and Executions in Minnesota. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. p. 67.
  10. Bessler 2003, p. 68
  11. Bessler 2003, p. 69
  12. Cecil 1997, p. 356
  13. Bessler 2003, p. 70-72
  14. Bessler 2003, p. 80
  15. Shipman 2002, p. 259
  16. Bessler 2003, p. 81
  17. Bessler 2003, p. 82
  18. Bessler 2003, p. 83
  19. Cecil 1997, p. 361
  20. Anderson, Michael (2002). "Minnesota's John Day Smith Law and the Death Penalty Debate". Minnesota History. 58: 84–91.
  21. Cecil 1997, p. 351
  22. Shipman 2002, p. 3, 16
  23. Shipman 2002, p. 18
  24. Shipman 2002, p. 260
  25. City Pages, March 22, 2000 Archived June 10, 2012, at the Wayback Machine

Further reading
  • Cairns, Kathleen (2013). Proof of Guilt: Barbara Graham and the Politics of Executing Women in America. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
  • Jones, Ann (1981). Women Who Kill. New York: Fawcett Columbine.
  • Lewis, Chad (2010). Haunted St. Paul. Charleston, SC: The History Press.
  • Linders, Annulla (2002). “The Execution Spectacle and State Legitimacy: The Changing Nature of the American Execution Audience”. Law and Society Review. 36: 607-656.
  • Segrave, Kerry (2008). Women and Capital Punishment in America, 1840-1899: Death Sentences and Executions in the United States and Canada. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
  • Trenerry, Walter N. (1962). Murder in Minnesota: A Collection of True Cases. Minnesota Historical Society. pp. 25–41. ISBN 978-0-87351-180-3.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.