It takes a *very* long time to eject my flashdrives

4

1

I am running a fresh install on Debian 8, and I often have to wait a ridiculous time before my flashdrives get ejected (ranging from 1 to 10.. 15 minutes). During this time, I can't access anything concerning the drive because I get the error An operation is already pending.

It seems like it has nothing to see with the flashdrive format (I've tried FAT, ext4, NTFS), but it also seems to start when I start putting files on them. (nothing heavy though, ~500Mb).

What could be causing this problem? Is there something I can do to speed up ejection?

iago-lito

Posted 2015-10-16T09:26:08.147

Reputation: 236

Answers

11

Although I don't know if this is the actual explanation/solution to your question, I believe this is an issue with USB in general.

If you copy large files or many files, the USB device will deliver a message to the host saying "I am about to send you these files". The device will then asynchronously send all files and will take the time it needs to do so. This means that when you do a cp /my/flash/drive/foo.txt /home/bar/foo.txt the device will tell the operating system that files are being copied and then send the files.

The only way I know of to check if all data actually has been transferred is to enter sync after doing a command that copies/moves or deletes files on a flash drive. The sync command will then just block until the drive is finished with transferring data. After that it should be safe to unmount/eject an USB flashdrive.

[EDIT]: Check this post to watch progress of the sync operation: the number printed when you run

watch grep -e Dirty: -e Writeback: /proc/meminfo

should decrease down to zero as background data transfers occur. When it's done, your sync will be completed and your flashdrive will eject.

Another common problem with ejecting USB storage devices is that atleast Debian will not allow it if there is a program, terminal or similar currently working on files/folders on that flash drive. So if you have changed directory to a folder on that flashdrive in a terminal and then try to eject the flash drive using another terminal, it will not allow that until you have changed directory to somewhere else not on the flashdrive in the first terminal.

Mogget

Posted 2015-10-16T09:26:08.147

Reputation: 1 186

Short answer: It takes a long time because the USB device is still transferring data you have copied, deleted, moved or is working on and refuse to eject the device until it has finished doing the previous command. – Mogget – 2015-10-16T10:40:34.157

Thanks for this explanation! Do you mean that the files might be still transfering even though I am finished with my copying job when I want to eject? Is it a LIE when the progress bar is over after click+drag or I return to command prompt after cp?! ;) – iago-lito – 2015-10-16T10:41:40.667

1Exactly! Just because the command you ran (cp, mv, rm or even a copy paste in Windows) and it finishes, doesn't mean that all the actual data has been transferred. It can still be transferring in the background. – Mogget – 2015-10-16T10:45:23.183

Crazy! So if I understand well, sync is the only reliable way of being sure that all data has been transfered, because it only returns when the work is done.. Side question: then when do cp returns and when do the gui progress bars reach "100%" ? What are they truly waiting for? – iago-lito – 2015-10-16T10:51:23.287

There are probaby other ways to check if the transfer is done or not, but I don't know of one. To be honest I don't know for sure what the OS is using. Maybe someone else on here knows the answer to that. – Mogget – 2015-10-16T10:55:30.950

1

Look at the first answer in this question; It explains some of the things I did not explain well. http://askubuntu.com/questions/122113/copy-to-usb-memory-stick-really-slow

– Mogget – 2015-10-16T11:00:34.363

I've actually found one now! Check my edit :) – iago-lito – 2018-04-16T08:18:14.293

Asked: 2015-10-16T09:26:08.147

Viewed: 6 794 times

Active: 2018-04-16T09:48:08.453