Should I backup to optical disc and why?

Question

I am considering including duplicating to bluray once or twice a year into my backup strategy and would appreciate input on pros and cons.

Advantages I assume:

• immune to EMP/electric surge

Disadvantages I assume:

• slow
• limited space
• only write once

Am I correct in my assumptions? What other advantages and disadvantages do this medium have? What is the life expectancy of an optical disc? How far from an atomic blast will they survive?

Edit: I do not feel that my question is a duplicate of the suggested questions. Their answers do contain relevant information but the questions themselves have a different primary focus.

Answer 1

You are on the right track with your assumptions.

Advantages:

1) Immune to EMP/electric surge:

In general day to day use, yes, especially when compared to say a hard drive. As for the EMP part (hopefully we never find out), it would depend on several conditions, though it would most likely survive much better than a HDD

Disadvantages:

1) Slow:

Depends on your equipment, particularly the speed of the Blu-ray optical drive being used. Wikipedia has a nice summary of speeds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blu-ray_Disc_recordable#Speed Hard drives and SSDs would most likely be faster.

2) Limited space:

Yes, Blu-rays have limited space per disk but so do any storage devices. Compared to modern consumer HDDs/SSDs the space per Blu-ray is relatively low, however, this is not really an issue as Blu-rays are generally significantly cheaper than a HDD/SSD of the same size.

3) Only write once:

If you use a single write Blu-ray, yes. Re-writable Blu-ray discs are also available.

This site is a good summary of the pros and cons of backing up to Blu-ray: http://www.databackuponlinestorage.com/Blu-ray_Optical_Discs

As stated per the link above, it is difficult to accurately state the life expectancy of a Blu-ray, although theoretically they could last 50-200 years. Practically, their lifespan is dependent on how long the Blu-ray standard is supported.

Like any optical disc, there are three primary dangers:

1. Direct sunlight
2. Excessive heat
3. Scratches

Scratches are easily avoided by storing them suitably, usually in a high quality 'disc wallet'. Heat is avoided by storing them in a relatively cool location, ideally no warmer than room temperature.

In terms of extreme surviving an atomic blast or something extreme, it's not very likely. Perhaps they would survive a flood for example, assuming they remain protected in a case. As for other disasters, chances are low.