Is my shift hitting the fan?

2

On my laptop, an odd problem has developed. Whenever I press my left shift key, I hear a funny high-pitched sound like something is spinning against it. No other key causes the effect. Is this likelier to be the fan, the hard disk (ulp!) or something else?

EDIT: Oh, sorry I didn't specify! My computer is an Asus U46E-BAL7.

As it happens, the problem somehow went away in the twelve-plus hours I've been away from the machine. I'm guessing ultrasawblade's guess was basically right; some detritus underneath the key could have been partly blocking the fan, causing the fan noise's pitch to change when the key was pressed. It's hard to imagine what else it was unless the CD/DVD drive was invovled.

Lenoxus

Posted 2014-02-27T02:40:12.990

Reputation: 53

1Is this a bad pun attempt or serious question? – Brian Adkins – 2014-02-27T02:47:23.930

Please specific the exact make and model. – Dan D. – 2014-02-27T03:29:27.810

Can you give us the laptop model so we can see what's under your left shift key? – miggy – 2014-02-27T03:53:44.450

The likelihood of having your "fan" directly under your keyboard is unlikely. In all honesty every keyboard has its own PCB so what you describe isn't even possible. – Ramhound – 2014-02-27T04:16:58.883

@ramhound not true. I've seen it on 2009 era macbooks - the glue holding the protective yellow tape degrades and corners of it can get pushed into the fan blades by heavy-handed typists (upper left and right in that case, not shift) – quadruplebucky – 2014-02-28T01:27:02.967

Answers

1

Is this likelier to be the fan, the hard disk (ulp!) or something else?

Since hard disks don't expose their platters, and there isn't anything else with moving parts in a laptop, it has to be the fan. Your laptop would probably stop immediately and not boot afterward if you were pressing hard enough on it to cause the head of the hard drive to hit the platter.

You may try dusting out your laptop's vents with some canned air - it could be that you're pushing some dust around in a weird way.

LawrenceC

Posted 2014-02-27T02:40:12.990

Reputation: 63 487