Computer Hardware Dilemma - Compatibility with Asus, Corsair and AMD

Question

I recently purchased these components:

Asus M5 A97 R2.0 Motherboard
Corsair DDR3 1866 MHz RAM 4X8GB (CMZ32GX3M4X1866C10R)
AMD 8-core FX 8150 Processor

I have an existing hard drive with Windows 7 64-bit that runs great, plus additional WD Cavier Green HDs for testing. I have extra RAM as well for testing.

I put the system together (with ample power) and upon booting to Windows I get a brief (not enough time to read) blue screen and system failure (reboot cycles).

I've fiddled with the MemOK! option on the board as well as used the AI Tweaker to adjust memory settings to no avail. I ran memory test on RAM with mixed results. Once it passed (all four 8 GB sticks and once it failed with hardware failure message).

I've tested existing sticks of RAM (both on the QVL compatibility matrix and not, both failing to boot with same blue screen, brief message and reboot cycle) and I've tried to reinstall Windows 7 on a new WD drive (mentioned above) with installation failures.

The computer I'm on now is running the versions of Windows 7 so I'm convinced the hard drive is good.

What is going on? I'm leaning towards the motherboard being faulty on arrival. I'm tempted to return all the components I bought and start over, but I'm not sure if this is the right choice. I'm no hardware expert, but I've built my share of systems and never run into this kind of issue.

I've read a bit about this motherboard giving nonspecific errors on boot with this RAM, so I'm a bit suspicious, but not really sure. I currently run similar RAM, so I've got a bit of experience with Corsair DDR... I really don't want to waste a whole bunch of time troubleshooting these components but I like them too, which is why I bought them in the first place.

Any tricks to sort this out?

EDIT

I went ahead and bought another motherboard (Gigabyte GA-970A-D3), because that was my hunch. I installed the hardware and the system booted just fine. OK, so far, so good. Then, for thoroughness, I ran the memory diagnostic in Windows boot and it told me there was a memory hardware problem.

The system runs good, except that it did reboot on its own after a power error (kernel power failure) and now I have these memory errors. So now either all the memory I've tested is somehow defective or there is another problem I haven't seen yet. I'm tempted to send back the memory and go with another brand but I don't want to seem hasty.

I'm thinking I should probably run a more sophisticated memory test so I can get more details. But I want to try to figure out if there is really a memory problem or if the hard drive, for example, could be somehow bad. Running chkdsk now to see if this turns up any errors.

EDIT

chkdsk /f of all partitions come up clean. Not sure if this means 100% that the disk is good, but it's a start. I think I'm leaning towards replacing the memory as well on this system.

Answer 1

After replacing all memory with new board system runs perfectly.

Answer 2

I'd suggest a motherboard failure aswell. I can't say what the exact cause for this is but I build a lot of PCs for companies as a part time job and experienced a few boards that booted and worked ok but I had very random and weird issues with the RAM even though its been listed on the QVL of the board.

"RMA'ing" those boards always resolved the issue and the new board worked fine with the same set of RAM modules. Given that you get this error with diffrent sets of RAM modules, makes me pretty sure it's a motherboard fault.

Before giving up on the board you should try to update the BIOS if you haven't already done that as BIOS updates often fix hardware issues.

Answer 3

That blue screen that goes by too fast for you to read is Windows' way of trying to tell you what's wrong. If you could read that screen, a quick Googling of the error message would probably tell you what's wrong.

Windows defaults to rebooting after a system failure - you need to turn that off. If you could actually boot into Windows, you would do that by:

• Control Panel\System and Security\System
• Advanced System Settings
• Startup and Recovery (push the button marked "Settings...")
• under System Failure, uncheck "Automatically restart".

However, you aren't able to boot to the desktop, so:

• as the computer is starting, after the ASUS logo disappears but before the Windows logo appears, press F8. You may miss the moment - if the Windows logo comes up, you were too slow - so I usually just hit F8 a whole bunch of times in the hope that one of them will "take".
• You should see the Advanced Boot Options menu.
• Arrow down to "Disable automatic restart on system failure" and press Enter.

Please be aware: this won't fix your problem - but it will enable you to collect enough information to actually ask a useful question.