On a dual-GPU laptop, is using the discrete GPU ever more power efficient?

3

Given a laptop with a dual integrated/discrete GPU configuration, is it ever more power efficient to use the discrete GPU instead of the integrated?

Obviously when writing an email or working on a spreadsheet, the integrated GPU will always use less power. But let's say you're doing something graphics-medium but not graphics-intensive/heavy - is there a point where it actually makes sense to fire up the discrete GPU, not for performance but for power-saving reasons?

Off the top of my head, I can think of a scenario where the external GPU supports hardware decoding of a particular video codec - I'd imagine there is a "price point" where using the GPU saves more energy than decoding that fully in software would. But I think most GPUs, integrated or discrete, pretty much decode just the plain-Jane h264.

But maybe there is something more complicated, perhaps if you're doing something like desktop/windowing animations or a flash animation on a website (not an embedded flash video) - maybe the discrete GPU will use enough less power to make up for switching to it?

I guess this question can be summed up as to whether or not you can say beyond doubt that if you don't care for performance on a laptop with two GPUs, always use the integrated GPU for maximum battery life.

Mahmoud Al-Qudsi

Posted 2012-11-20T04:08:57.943

Reputation: 3 274

Question was closed 2012-11-20T10:58:04.297

when all power saving options are enabled(when all components are allowed to save power) using hardware acceleration will generally yield power efficient results. – Uğur Gümüşhan – 2016-07-03T02:37:07.937

Very interesting question. Never thought this way. +1 – pratnala – 2012-11-20T05:39:32.817

I was about to ask the same here, I always have this doubt in mind. Too bad they closed it! Did you find anything about it? – Roberto – 2014-01-10T09:32:11.630

2What can we do for this to be reopened? I don't even know why it was considered not constructive. – Roberto – 2014-01-10T09:36:44.543

No answers