Can touching any hardware inside a running PC be dangerous for you?

33

4

I'm curious, if all the hardware gets power from the PSU's DC power lines, which provide a max. voltage of 12V, can you get electrocuted by touching some of the hardware?

develroot

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 719

7For safety reasons, you might still want to turn off everything. Power spikes, lightning, malfunctioning equipment and such things can get you electrocuted. Better to avoid it even if it sounds safe than to be sorry. I had a electrical fly killer electrocute my entire right arm, and I thought it was entirely safe to hold it by the net... – Tamara Wijsman – 2011-10-09T19:32:29.807

39 V is enough to kill you. – stardt – 2011-10-10T01:14:06.267

1Except in extraordinary circumstances, a voltage in excess of about 50 volts is needed to cause electrocution. Not to say that such circumstances couldn't occur inside a running PC, but it would be a stroke of extraordinarily bad luck. – Daniel R Hicks – 2011-10-10T02:16:13.273

2The darwin awards have proven anything is dangerous and fatal in the wrong hands. If you don't know what you are doing leave it to the professionals or take a few electronics classes. – Moab – 2011-10-10T03:49:23.533

This happens to me many times, and the problem is always with me only, Every other people can touch the PC without problems. I might be a problem of static discharging. – Yousf – 2011-10-10T12:11:47.257

2Nitpick: electrocution means being killed by electrical shock. You can be shocked multiple times. You can only be electrocuted once. – Steve Fallows – 2011-10-11T13:45:29.613

@develroot +1 for great question – linuxrules94 – 2011-10-21T16:05:49.167

Answers

33

The short answer is no, 12 volts isn't high enough and the 24 rail to rail voltage available is from an unbalanced pair of connections, -12V is pretty limited on current output.

The long answer is yes, a faulty power supply with a bad ground connection (third prong) can kill you. Older machines ran mains power up to the on/off switch and a hot wire laying over a sharp edge could put full mains power on the chassis. But then the system doesn't have to be open, just touching the metal case would do it.

While you hear about the occasional electrocution from computers in the news (bad ground circuits), the likelyhood of working on an open system harming you is extremely low to nil. Now where you get into trouble is working with old CRT monitors. The flyback transformer system output starts at about 8.000 volts and the tube is a neat Leyden Jar, just waiting to bite when fingers get into the wrong areas and kill when the current travels from arm to arm. Having taken 80kV from a General Motors HEI ignition system, I can tell you from experience you don't want to do this. LCD backlight systems also are another area to avoid as you're dealing with 90-400V depending on the system.

Protecting the system from you often is more likely to be an issue. Having drawn a one inch static spark on a motherboard once and not having anything happen for me was a stroke of luck. Ground straps are probably a good idea.

Update on human physiology. Grab an ohm meter with autoranging and perform the following experiment. With dry hands, put it on a fairly high setting with a lead in either hand and the test probes in contact with the backs of your hands. Note the resistance. Now hold the probe tips between your fingers and slowly squeeze. Get some salt water, soak your hands and hold the probe tips in your fingers. Note now the resistance changes.

Most people don't understand Ohm's law: voltage divided by resistance = current. So a 5 volt power supply capable of 50 amps is only able to push 0.0025 amp through a 2000 ohm resistance. 110 volts can push 0.055 amp through 2000 ohms and 1000 volts can push 0.5 amp through 2000 ohms. The general test for body impedance is from arm to arm (across your heart). People have died from as low as 32 Volts.

The usual accepted lethal current is 0.100 amp (100 milliamps) and is determined by voltage applied, skin resistance and the path it takes through your body in an attempt to find its opposite polarity or ground. Basically the rule is 100mA for fib and 200mA for total heart contraction.

And the reason static from the carpet doesn't kill you is because while you have a tremendous voltage buildup, there isn't enough charge there (quantity of electrons) to carry a sustained current, power supply systems on the other hand are designed to do this.

Fiasco Labs

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 6 368

1+1 for mentioning CRTs, they can really hurt you. – Handyman5 – 2011-10-09T23:11:29.173

CRTs can crush! Thankfully they're all but gone now – Kurru – 2011-10-10T02:29:11.793

I was always told that "it's the current that kills you, and computer power-supplies can't deliver enough current," which is why they're dangerous. This has always confused me, because I'm sure the mains could deliver more than enough to kill you. However, if it's simply that there's not enough voltage, why are car batteries (12V) considered dangerous while PC power supplies (also 12V) are not? – BlueRaja - Danny Pflughoeft – 2011-10-10T07:08:32.297

@BlueRaja, If we are talking about unfused connections, a car battery can deliver huge amounts of power (I don't have any source handy, but have seen figures in the hundreds of amps range, which makes sense - that works out to a few kilowatts, which sounds about right to get the engine started). A computer power supply always has at least one fuse, so with a regular PSU you'll blow the fuse before you get anywhere near that kind of power. That's not to say shorting an energized PSU's output leads can't be dangerous, but they are very different critters. – a CVn – 2011-10-10T07:58:01.007

@Michael: I was under the impression that less than one amp could easily kill a person - so even with just the dozen or so amps a PC power-supply could deliver, shouldn't it still be dangerous?

– BlueRaja - Danny Pflughoeft – 2011-10-10T08:15:17.460

@BlueRaja, I believe it depends on the path the current takes through the body. Some people get thrown across the room from touching live 230VAC wiring and live to tell the tale, others die from the 9VDC of a regular battery. Then again, why risk it? – a CVn – 2011-10-10T08:24:36.107

I once get hitted by electricity from my computer. It wasn't nice. :( – daGrevis – 2011-10-10T16:48:11.677

4Human physiology. Grab an ohm meter with autoranging and perform the following experiment. With dry hands, put it on a fairly high setting with a lead in either hand and the test probes in contact with the backs of your hands. Note the resistance. Now hold the probe tips between your fingers and slowly squeeze. Get some salt water, soak your hands and hold the probe tips in your fingers. Note now the resistance changes. – Fiasco Labs – 2011-10-10T18:59:04.763

3The problem with most people is that they don't understand Ohm's law. Voltage divided by resistance = current. So a 5volt power supply capable of 50 amps is only able to push 0.0025 amp through a 2000 ohm resistance. 110 volts can push 0.055 amp through 2000 ohms and 1000 volts can push 0.5 amp through 2000 ohms. The general test for body impedance is from arm to arm (across your heart). People have died from as low as 32 Volts – Fiasco Labs – 2011-10-10T19:06:43.630

3The usual accepted lethal current is 0.100 amp (100 milliamps) and is determined by voltage applied, skin resistance and the path it takes through your body in an attempt to find its opposite polarity or ground. Basically the rule is 100mA for fib and 200mA for total heart contraction. – Fiasco Labs – 2011-10-10T19:14:22.403

3And the reason static from the carpet doesn't kill you is because while you have a tremendous voltage buildup, there isn't enough charge there (quantity of electrons) to carry a sustained current, power supply systems otoh are designed to do this. – Fiasco Labs – 2011-10-10T19:19:34.940

+1 for Human physiology ohm meter experiment. @FiascoLabs – linuxrules94 – 2011-10-10T20:29:15.013

+1 ok so a power supply rated as 50A as in your example, means it can push 50A through a resistance of 1 ohm. interesting.. One thing worth mentioning though is what the resistance of the human body is in ohms. According to yahoo answers "Human body has different resistances, when dry, resistance is 100.000 ohms. When wet because of sweat or water, resistance is only 1,000 ohms" – barlop – 2012-12-15T10:34:02.923

First things first, power supply amp ratings are due to the design of the power supply which is dependent on the components and input voltage/current. A power supply rated at 50A, what voltage output? Voltage is the force that pushes the current. A 5V power supply rated at 50A will supply 50A when given a 0.100 ohm load. voltage/amperage = circuit resistance or 5V/50A = 0.100 ohm. A 24V power supply rated at 50A will supply 50A on a 0.480 Ohm load. – Fiasco Labs – 2012-12-15T17:27:31.987

1A power supply rated at 50A would need to be 50 Volts to push 50A through a 1 ohm resistor – Fiasco Labs – 2012-12-15T17:34:48.493

11

One tip if you happen to be working in an older (pre-ATX) computer - The wires going to and from the switch on the front of the case are carrying the same voltage as the electrical outlet. I shocked myself several times brushing up against the connection between the switch and the wire when the plastic guard had gotten dislodged.

I believe this goes back to the original PC-AT power supply design with the switch integrated into the supply. When they decided to move the switch to the front of the case, the simplest thing to do was to run the 120/240V power to the switch and then back to the power supply.

dsolimano

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 2 778

@ChadLevy Not according to the dictionary it doesn't. Etymology isn't equivalent to definition. And isn't being struck by lightning being electrocuted or the same thing? Yet many people do survive it. Anyway electrocution is being shocked it's just it causes injury or death. – Pryftan – 2019-09-03T14:57:37.747

3You probably shocked yourself. Electrocution (in the proper use of the word) is usually fatal. – Chad Levy – 2011-10-09T19:32:46.597

2Excellent point @Paperjam, I have corrected my poor usage. – dsolimano – 2011-10-09T19:39:56.433

2@Tom, the power supply was not broken, that's just the way they were wired back in the day - references added. – dsolimano – 2011-10-09T19:40:33.487

+1 - Don't want to admit it, but, I did exactly the same years ago! I shocked myself by touching the connector for the front panel button! – William Hilsum – 2011-10-10T02:49:14.710

I prefer "I electrified myself" :-> – Moab – 2011-10-10T03:47:08.543

1The AT-standard only allowed for "hard" power switches, e.g. the switch physically cut the mains supply to the PSU like a light switch. The ATX standard defined a "soft" power switch that allows the motherboard to control the PSU power by supplying the proper voltage on the control line. The downside is that the PSU is required to provide a small line that is constantly on - to allow the computer to power up. The plus side is that you can shutdown/restart/powerup the computer in software. – crasic – 2011-10-10T08:30:52.667

11

Yes, there is a chance to be injured

1. You can get burned badly by a CPU. (especially laptops)

2. Direct contact (for instance if a sharp a solder joint penetrates the skin allowing good contact & low resistance) with as little as ~20mA can stop or cause fibrillation of the heart. (I once touched a 12v solenoid and it caused me to accidentally hit my face with my wrist hard :D )

Assuming that the power supply is 100 Watts for each rail:

100w / 12v  = 8.3a
100w / 5v   = 20a
100w / 3.3v = 30.3a

Assuming that the power supply is 600 Watts for each rail:

600w / 12v  = 50a
600w / 5v   = 120a
600w / 3.3v = 182a

...

Table from: http://www.allaboutcircuits.com/vol_1/chpt_3/4.html

BODILY EFFECT     DIRECT CURRENT (DC)    60 Hz AC     10 kHz AC
--------------------------------------------------------------- 
Slight sensation     Men = 1.0 mA         0.4 mA        7 mA 
felt at hand(s)    Women = 0.6 mA         0.3 mA        5 mA 
--------------------------------------------------------------- 
Threshold of         Men = 5.2 mA         1.1 mA       12 mA 
perception         Women = 3.5 mA         0.7 mA        8 mA 
--------------------------------------------------------------- 
Painful, but          Men = 62 mA           9 mA       55 mA 
voluntary muscle    Women = 41 mA           6 mA       37 mA 
control maintained                                           
--------------------------------------------------------------- 
Painful, unable       Men = 76 mA          16 mA       75 mA 
to let go of wires  Women = 51 mA        10.5 mA       50 mA 
--------------------------------------------------------------- 
Severe pain,          Men = 90 mA          23 mA       94 mA 
difficulty          Women = 60 mA          15 mA       63 mA 
breathing                                                    
--------------------------------------------------------------- 
Possible heart        Men = 500 mA        100 mA             
fibrillation        Women = 500 mA        100 mA             
after 3 seconds                                              
--------------------------------------------------------------- 

...

Ever licked a 9v battery to test it? Low voltage can be quite shocking ;-)

...

Quoting Fiasco Labs

Human physiology. Grab an ohm meter with autoranging and perform the following experiment. With dry hands, put it on a fairly high setting with a lead in either hand and the test probes in contact with the backs of your hands. Note the resistance. Now hold the probe tips between your fingers and slowly squeeze. Get some salt water, soak your hands and hold the probe tips in your fingers. Note now the resistance changes. – Fiasco Labs

3. Accidental contact with fan (I did this before it HURTS!)

linuxrules94

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 145

1Thanks for posting that chart, I had one in one of my old Electronics textbooks and was wishing to add it. As to the relay, another effect most people don't know about is that the pull-in coil has a self-induced voltage spike when the current is cut off to it and its field collapses. If you're driving this relay with a solid state circuit, you need to place a diode across the coil (reverse polarity) to effectively short the coil to itself so the voltage spike doesn't get back into your driver transistors and smoke them. – Fiasco Labs – 2011-10-10T21:11:30.120

you're welcome, i remember hearing using a diode on inductive loads too (I wonder if speakers do it too) – linuxrules94 – 2011-10-13T00:57:33.197

9

A spinning fan or sharp edge inside the case are more common "dangerous" concerns within a computer :)

Kurru

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 1 476

2i know that) i have once broke a blade of a cpu's fan. instead, my finger was perfectly fine =) – develroot – 2011-10-10T12:28:55.743

Had one of those first high speed ball bearing heat sink fans that run about 5500 rpm (whiny thing) on an Athlon processor. It drew blood as I saw the blade depart the case and head across the room. Thankfully it had an even blade count, so I snapped one off on the other side and filed the stubs down till both were in balance. It ran for years that way, and I swear just enough quieter to make it tolerable. Sharp case edges are another matter. I had a scar trail down my arm from a washing machine. All these things are built by a coining process that leaves razor sharp micro sawblade edges. – Fiasco Labs – 2011-10-13T01:30:34.843

9

  1. You can get burned on a hot heat-sink.
  2. You can get a finger nicked on a fan blade.
  3. If you're wearing any jewelry you can get a ring or watchband or what-have-you between the main 5V supply and ground. There is enough current there to cause serious burns, perhaps enough to cause loss of a finger if, eg, your ring gets heated to red hot. (In general, modern desktop power supplies are sufficiently current-limited that the chance of serious injury is minimal, but in a high-powered box the 5V supply is still delivering enough current to produce this sort of hazard. It is REALLY a hazard in "big iron" boxes where hundreds of amps are available, and where safety rules demand that all jewelry be removed before working inside.)
  4. If you're wearing any jewelry you can get a ring or watchband or what-have-you between two points in the circuit and burn out a $500 component, after which you'll kill yourself.

Daniel R Hicks

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 5 783

I just got a bit burned yesterday by a laptop motherboard hot-component, my finger is fine now, I guess that's different from getting electrocuted, right? Sorry for the silly question, I'm just a bit worried. – Dan – 2019-11-25T10:10:07.407

-3

You have asked the question which is a good reason to leave well alone. There are parts that could be trashed if you touch them (static), or if you drop something on them. Power supplies usually come with an extra level of metal shielding, but really, call in the repair man.

Paddy3118

Posted 2011-10-09T19:10:58.487

Reputation: 164

1@Zach Not everyone is an electrician. They're trained. Ridiculous suggestion you made. Opening a PSU is not the same thing as servicing a computer. +1 for this answer. That with that it's now -3 is .. shocking... really. Even if it can be done does not mean it should be done. And is an answer that points out safety actually negative? That anyone thinks that is appalling. Your analogy in any case is flawed to the earth. Not everyone wants to be an electrician. But *many people will do things* that are dangerous because they also follow statements like yours. How is that not obvious? – Pryftan – 2019-09-03T15:02:35.660

6I'd -1 if I had enough reputation. If everyone followed this advice, there would be no repair men (or women). Learning to service the insides of a machine is best done by experience. The inside of a PC is basically not dangerous to a healthy adult human, even with power running through it, but of course it's safest to turn it off and unplug it. – Zach – 2011-10-09T22:04:53.800

3Hi Zach. Enough gung-ho individuals thought as you do to demote my answer anyway. I am concerned that the original poster seemed like a rookie and was not asking for help from a person but from the web. I don't want that kind of person in my computer room taking the back off any of my servers without a more experienced person guiding him. No drivers on the road without tuition and L'plates thank you! – Paddy3118 – 2011-10-10T06:55:16.747

Fair enough... if the OP was someone who would be working on my machines, I would not want him or her asking this question. But if he or she is a hobbyist at home just curious about taking apart and working on computers, then I'm all for it. – Zach – 2011-10-10T21:48:19.697

1+1 for overly zealous -1'ers with no explanations. – HaydnWVN – 2011-11-28T10:12:59.697

@Zach - Yeah, if someone was asking this over in Server Fault, I'd be worried. – Fiasco Labs – 2013-03-09T02:47:48.767