ISP mail server blocking me?

3

I'm currently writing an email client for fun/practice and I've noticed that after sending out a handful of test emails (10 or so) over a short period of time, the emails stop going through. At some point later I'm able to send again from the client and the process starts over.

Is it possible that my ISP's mail server is detecting me and temporarily blocking me? And if that is the case, why are they doing that, and is there another way for me to test my mail client?

Ryan

Posted 2011-05-13T06:55:33.140

Reputation: 1 488

Answers

5

Yes. The ISP is probably implementing "rate limiting" to thwart the efforts of spammers.

  • Spammers don't like to be delayed because they are victimizing millions of recipients in as short a time as possible (it's a race against having their web site or other services shut down, so they want to get the maximum number of responses before the inevitable cut-off).

You could install a local SMTP server for your testing purposes. One that I like is Mercury/32, which works quite well even in high-volume scenarios (I used it to process over 50,000 eMail messages per day for a large and diverse user base for many years):

  Mercury/32 and Pegasus Mail by David Harris
  http://www.pmail.com/

enter image description here

Randolf Richardson

Posted 2011-05-13T06:55:33.140

Reputation: 14 002

Does my ISP's mail server single me out as a possible spammer because I haven't registered this IP address as a mail server with them? – Ryan – 2011-05-13T07:18:34.607

1Probably not, because most ISPs just arbitrarily block outbound TCP port 25 traffic to everywhere except their own internal eMail servers (so their users can send eMail) -- this prevents what is called "direct-to-MX mailing" by spammers using Spamware designed to send eMail directly to each victim's SMTP server, and it also prevents open SMTP relay abuse (another technique used by spammers to abuse the internet). If you do need to run an SMTP server, then you'll need to get a Static IP address from your ISP and have a PTR record configured in their DNS ARPA zone (yeah, "registered"). – Randolf Richardson – 2011-05-13T07:21:59.023

1

@Ryan Yes, there are a couple of other things to consider too. An MX record would help. What other ISPs may do is "ask" if your IP address really belongs to a registered mail server. Also, a RFC-conform client that sends its correct host name is sometimes needed. Or a client that correctly communicates with greylisting servers. As I said, there are lots of things nowadays :)

– slhck – 2011-05-13T07:24:50.973

I wasn't looking to run my own mail server. I mainly just wanted to write my own email client and use it. Is there a way I can do just that without having the ~10 email limit before timeout? – Ryan – 2011-05-13T07:31:13.653

1@Ryan As @Randolf said, just test it locally, Mercury is good, if you can run Linux there are a couple of alternatives as well. – slhck – 2011-05-13T08:13:05.327

Right! Sorry, my mind was stuck on what I'm doing not being a mail server, when in reality it acts like one. A true mail client would only interact with a mail server, not generate its own emails. Thank you! – Ryan – 2011-05-13T22:15:07.217

Asked: 2011-05-13T06:55:33.140

Viewed: 311 times

Active: 2011-05-13T07:14:24.507