Caviar Green HDD extremely slow

I found a 1.5TB drive that was used for backups (those drives have been upgraded to 2TB) that I thought might be good to use as a secondary drive.

I plugged it into a esata port and it seemed to work (couldn't do a real test as it was formatted to ext3 and this computer is running Windows XP) so I plugged it internally, but on boot it was not recognised. I found if I used a molex to sata power adapter it would work but not using the sata power connector itself. (I have an Antec EarthWatts 500W PSU: it should be enough, my graphics card only takes power from the motherboard)

However it took four days to do a slow format.

I found a testing program and it reported a read speed of 3.7MB/s:

enter image description here

My other harddrives performed the same test at around 100MB/s:

enter image description here

Is this drive stuffed or is there something else I could do?

EDIT: OK I think it is stuffed: Found this in Event Viewer (along with hundreds of "The device, \Device\Harddisk1\D, has a bad block."):

The driver has detected that device \Device\Harddisk1\DR1 has predicted that it will fail. Immediately back up your data and replace your hard disk drive. A failure may be imminent.

You could probably ignore this post now!

hood

Posted 2011-05-03T21:05:48.113

Reputation: 33

What "stuffed hard drive" means? – Boris_yo – 2011-05-03T21:38:58.473

@Boris_yo Stuffed is sometimes used to mean damaged, damaged beyond repair or in need of replacement. I believe that the word was used with one of those meanings in the edit. – AndrejaKo – 2011-05-03T22:11:05.303

@Boris_yo: sorry about using slang. "Stuffed" is indeed similar to "broken" or "damaged beyond repair". – hood – 2011-05-03T23:22:40.250

you should post your last edit as an answer – Sathyajith Bhat – 2011-05-04T09:10:50.073

I have a WD Green, so does my friend. Both of our drives are dying, and they are about the same age. SMART only shows FAIL/PRE-FAIL values, condition is 0%. The drives are still spinning, and the WD utility shows them 100% intact/perfect (while they are obviously not).

Hence, we can't return them. So yeah. 2 dead WD Green, lying around without any use. (One 500gb and a 1TB drive.) – Apache – 2011-05-04T09:19:17.243

Answers

Sounds like you have your answer. Is the drive still under warranty? A quick check here should tell. If so, you may have a new one for little cost beyond shipping.

WD Warranty

Dave M

Posted 2011-05-03T21:05:48.113

Reputation: 12 811

I've started the RMA process. I thought it'd be out of warranty but it was accepted! (Now to send it to Singapore...) – hood – 2011-05-05T12:07:38.870

If you are lucky you may get a larger drive. It has happened to me a few times. Often not but when it does it is a nice bonus. – Dave M – 2011-05-05T14:01:54.987

The cheapest postage I could get was $30 (without insurance, express, registered, etc), which seems a little high for something apparently worth $70. :-( – hood – 2011-05-13T03:16:14.603

I got an email saying the replacement drive has been shipped and I should get it in a few days (shipping from Singapore to Australia). Judging by the product number (WD20EADS) I'm getting a 2TB!

This whole ordeal has been relatively painless; I'd definitely buy and recommend WD again. – hood – 2011-05-30T11:57:43.943

You should get at least 60 Mb/S on a Caviar Green. Try defragging the drive, leaving at least 15% free (so 225 MB).

bobobobo

Posted 2011-05-03T21:05:48.113

Reputation: 4 632

It was newly formatted, so no files, so no fragmentation – hood – 2011-05-03T23:19:56.023

Besides, that testing program performs low-level operations and is unaffected by anything on a filesystem. – hood – 2011-05-03T23:23:49.763