What is the best solution for ad blocking with FireFox and Explorer 8?

5

What is the best way to block annoying ads but allow useful ads on Firefox and Explorer (8), basically I would like to:

  • block animated flash ads
  • block animated silverlight ads
  • block animated gif ads
  • allow subtle google ads and ads on e.g. StackOverflow which are graphics but often useful information
  • allow flash in general
  • allow silverlight in general
  • allow animated gif in general

What is the best way to strike this balance?

Edward Tanguay

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 11 955

Question was closed 2012-06-16T16:57:08.407

Answers

7

On Firefox it's relatively easy. Use AdBlock plus, but define your own custom rules. I added an exception for stackoverflow.com and other sites I like and support. It also has the ability to block flash ads, which is nice.

I haven't really used IE lately, but from what I understand, IE8, if used in "InPrivate Browsing" mode, will block certain ads.

alex

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 16 172

2

An interesting alternative system-wide solution would be using your HOSTS file.

Quoting from http://www.mvps.org/winhelp2002/hosts.htm :

The Hosts file contains the mappings of IP addresses to host names. This file is loaded into memory (cache) at startup, then Windows checks the Hosts file before it queries any DNS servers, which enables it to override addresses in the DNS. This prevents access to the listed sites by redirecting any connection attempts back to the local (your) machine. Another feature of the HOSTS file is its ability to block other applications from connecting to the Internet, providing the entry exists.

You can use a HOSTS file to block ads, banners, 3rd party Cookies, 3rd party page counters, web bugs, and even most hijackers. This is accomplished by blocking the connection(s) that supplies these little gems.

Example - the following entry 127.0.0.1 ad.doubleclick.net blocks all files supplied by that DoubleClick Server to the web page you are viewing. This also prevents the server from tracking your movements. Why? ... because in certain cases "Ad Servers" like Doubleclick (and many others) will try to open a separate connection on the webpage you are viewing.

Evert

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 1 075

+1 I love this method. Very elegant and efficient. Eliminates overhead and cross-browser concerns. – DLH – 2010-07-19T17:22:15.177

This would work for both Firefox and IE (and any other browser you might use). You could use Adblock in Firefox to generate the block list and then copy that to your hosts file. – ChrisF – 2009-08-21T11:27:14.380

One could also use a text based browser to get rid of most ads. ;-) Really, why maintaining a hosts file (or, like some suggest: a block list on http://www.opendns.com) if excellent add-ons like Adblock Plus, or proxies like http://www.privoxy.org/ update themselves automatically?

– Arjan – 2009-08-21T13:55:01.270

2

Firefox: adblock plus (http://adblockplus.org/en/)

IE8: InPrivate filter (config -> advanced config -> import)

import this file (download it to you pc and extract it first): http://www.dslreports.com/r0/download/1435747~4c279e6c324ef5b952c748a8932aa674/rules.xml.zip

tomorrow__

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 927

1

AdMuncher is probably what you need. It updates an ad list regularly. And it can distinguish between good flash and ad flash. For example, in Hulu.com, it will show the episode, but intercept the ads.

You can also whitelist sites, like SO if you choose. I've use it with Chrome and it makes browsing a very quiet experience.

Supports:

...Internet Explorer, Firefox, Opera, Google Chrome, Safari, Flock, Netscape, Maxthon and Avant Browser.

BTW, it does cost $30, but I got it free with Trial Pay by buying a $5 T-shirt from VistaPrint.

hyperslug

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 12 882

1

Proxomitron is the most effective web filter (and it's free).

Molly7244

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation:

1

+1 For adblock+

Excellent extension for firefox. What I love is you can just right click any ad and select "Block"

Its very flexible.

Or, try out http://www.privoxy.org/ if you want something even more effective and flexible to your needs.

Blam

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 246

0

In addition to previous great answers, you can control Flash ads with FlashBlock

user7963

Posted 2009-08-21T08:51:05.833

Reputation: 1 397