Can I install a laptop 2.5" SATA drive on a desktop without any adapters?

15

My girlfriend's computer has had the disk so I'm going to reinstall the operating system. However, before I do this I need to get all the data onto another machine. As the laptop won't stay on long enough to do this across the network I'm going to take out the laptop's hard and transplant it.

Before I left for work I promised I'd do it tonight. However, I just remembered that last time I did this with an IDE drive I needed a converter. Is the same true of SATA drives or will I just be able to use the same SATA and power cables I already have?


Update: Plugged it in and all worked happily.

jammus

Posted 2009-07-15T14:42:41.473

Reputation: 1 274

Answers

20

The cabling is the same between SATA drives from 2.5" and 3.5", so you should be fine using the same SATA cables. You may need an enclosure adapter to ensure that the drive stays put when you put it in a 3.5" bay, however.

Marcus Griep

Posted 2009-07-15T14:42:41.473

Reputation: 318

4Hello blu-tack. – jammus – 2009-07-15T14:49:05.660

2@jammus - the problem with blu-tac is that it gets soft when warm. It then either makes a difficult to clean mess, or fails to hold the drive in position, or both. I found out the hard way ;-) I don't really have a better solution though. – Stewart – 2009-07-27T13:20:58.550

Pieces of bike tube can sometimes be useful... – asjo – 2009-07-27T15:26:50.757

1

Yes, so long as the drive fits securely in the available space, a 2.5" SATA drive should work in place of a 3.5" drive, or visa versa, without special adaptors.

In fact, after only a tiny amount of tinkering, I currently have a 2.5" drive in a NAS device intended for 3.5" drives and a 3.5" drive in an external USB enclosure designed for 2.5" drives!

Stewart

Posted 2009-07-15T14:42:41.473

Reputation: 131

1

SATA connectors don't differ between 2.5" and 3.5" drives. Sometimes the connectors might be a little close, but they should work.

Russ Warren

Posted 2009-07-15T14:42:41.473

Reputation: 2 523

1

1,8" SATA need a special connector from miniSATA to SATA. All others are the same.

About mounting - 2.5" and 1.8" drives are very light, you can easily fix them with some mounting tape. If you don't need hot swap, this is the best and cheapest choice.

JvK

Posted 2009-07-15T14:42:41.473

Reputation: 111