Index/Match function to return all values based on multiple criteria

Question

I have an Excel document where I am trying to list all values that match three criteria.

Sheet1:

Year   Player   Pos   Cluster
2018   Joe      C      1
2018   Ken      RW     2
2018   Bill     C      1
2018   Ryan     C      1  
2017   Joe      C      1
2017   Ken      RW     2

I would like to return all player names that match off of year, pos, and cluster given a name.

Here's what Sheet 2 should look like like:

Player    Pos     Cluster
Joe       C       1

Similar Players
Bill
Ryan

Here's the function I wrote, but it only returns the same name:

=INDEX('Base Player Data'!B:B,MATCH(1,('Base Player Data'!AZ:AZ='Individual Player Projections'!K1)*('Base Player Data'!A:A='Individual Player Projections'!B6)*('Base Player Data'!E:E='Individual Player Projections'!E1),0))

Any Help Would Be Greatly Appreciated!