NVENC HVEC in FFMPEG unsharp on fast movement

Question

I use FFMPEG with NVENC HVEC and tried several options the last days but finally i was not able to reach the same quality as CPU Encoding. The main issue here is that fast scenes are getting unsharp. I read in some article that Twitch and YouTube are using GPU Encoder to compress videos, so the first question is, is it possible to reach the same quality with GPU Encoding with lower filesize or how are they doing this?

The second questions is if i'm doing something wrong here with my ffmpeg command or some idea to finetune it, as example i found some article that is telling "CRF" does not have an effect with x265 nvenc, other meanwhile told that this still works and this is confusing me. Here is my command

-y -preset slow -c:v hevc_nvenc -vf scale=1920x1080:flags=lanczos -rc cbr_ld_hq -rc-lookahead 32 -q 20 -r 60  -crf 19 -b:v 6.4M -movflags +faststart -c:a ac3 -b:a 320k -pass 1 -2pass -1 "D:\-=streaming=-\concats\x265-website_high.mp4"

Is there something i can do to compress it even better without using the CPU Encoder?

Answer 1

My experience with NVENC is, that it really is inferior to x264 / x265 CPU encoding, especially on fast moving or detail-rich scenes.

This implies, that in a CBR scenario your setup works as expected. There might be some tuning possible with your ffmpeg setup, but the principle still stands. YouTube doesn't use real CBR, and this might be one of the reasons.

One experience: The newer your NV SDK and your FFmpeg build, the better the results - seems there is quite a lot of active development going on.