8
1
As the subject says, I cannot get an XP guest to produce sound on my Windows 7 Ultimate 32bit host. Sound works fine in the host OS.
If I set the host audio driver to "Null Audio Driver" and the audio controller to ICH AC97, all appears to work, except no sound comes out the speakers. The Intel AC'97 Audio Controller shows up in my list of devices. As I understand it, that's what happens with Null Audio Driver. If you want sound, you need to select the Windows DirectSound for the host audio driver. If I do this, though, then when I start up the XP guest, it hangs with a dialog box titled "XPPro: Starting virtual machine" and the message "Starting virtual machine..." with a progress bar stuck at 0%. Here are the last few lines of my log file:
00:00:00.840 NAT: adding 24.116.2.50 to DNS server list
00:00:00.840 NAT: adding 24.116.2.34 to DNS server list
00:00:00.840 NAT: value of BindIP has been ignored
00:00:00.841 Audio: Trying driver 'dsound'.
00:00:00.936 Audio: set_record_source ars=0 als=0 (not implemented)
At that point the only thing I can do is kill the startup window. Setting the controller to soundblaster 16 lets the guest come up, but no audio device shows up in device manager or in the control panel app.
Any ideas how I can get sounds out of my guest OS?
UPDATE
I just finished installing VMware 3.0 and loading XP Pro there. Works like a charm. On the VBox forums, I was asked to submit a bug report, I guess there is an issue there.
i'll give it a try – DCookie – 2010-01-28T20:11:32.590
I cannot create a new machine - it hangs on the same error if I select Windows DirectSound. I'm using 3.1.2 as well.... – DCookie – 2010-01-29T02:40:43.833
@DCookie this sounds almost exactly like an audio driver issue with your host. – Goyuix – 2010-01-29T14:58:42.367
1Well, it's selective then :-) VMWare has no problems (at least with audio, I haven't done much else yet). +1, and my thanks, for the response. – DCookie – 2010-02-03T00:50:17.867
@DCookie I was going to suggest you report this in the VirtualBox forums and log a bug in the bugtracker, but it looks like you may have already done this. Version 3.1.4 is currently in beta, maybe a future update will fix whatever is broken. – Goyuix – 2010-02-03T17:35:45.857
Haven't actually logged the bug yet. I did reinstall drivers. I even reinstalled Win7. Neither the Win7 default drivers nor the latest RealTek drivers fix the issue. In your last paragraph, are you talking about in the host OS? – DCookie – 2010-02-03T18:57:31.267
@DCookie I have updated the answer to clarify changing the host audio properties. – Goyuix – 2010-02-04T15:31:41.493
There's a lot of good info in your answer, so even though it really didn't solve my problem I'll accept it for want of anything better... – DCookie – 2010-03-02T00:10:36.547