5
1
NAS seems to cost about the same price as a cheap desktop.
On the one hand the NAS has a dedicated Linux distro, but I could put OpenNAS, FreeNAS, etc, on a desktop PC.
If I go wth a desktop and network sharing on the drives, I can still use the "server" as a normal PC.
So - for home use, not business - why would I want to buy a NAS?
[Update (after the question was put on hold]
I agree that many of the comments are opinion based - and they are not helping me. Are there any technical reason, one way or another? Price may be used as an argument.
Btw in my case, the NAS/server would be used primarily as backup for the other PCs on the LAN. If I go for NAS, it won't be a major pain that I can't use it as a PC. With a server, I might do once a month, if even that often.
@holders - is that a good enough rewording, or can I improve it? I would be happy for one of you to edit the question, if you think that it can be asked without being opinion based. I really would like to hear a compelling case.
2Honestly I don't know - its why I have a Home Server at home instead of a NAS - not only is it more flexible and capable (power draw is dominated by the hardddrives in both cases) but it was also cheaper. (A Dell T20 back in 2014) – DetlevCM – 2015-12-06T17:47:46.737
It depends on a lot of things. Just a desktop PC plus $/Eur 1000 windows license is a lot. And a proper server grade PC even adds more. Both incapability and in cost. – Hennes – 2015-12-06T20:40:31.183
1@Hennes Linux does not cost a penny. Also, why spend 1000€ on a desktop PC? My Dell T20 was 167€ + drives & Sata card, 620€ total. far away from the 1000€ you quote. Even if I were stupid enough to buy Microsoft's Small Business Server, that's "only" 350€ (Home Server was around 100€ if you bought just the license). - Incidentally, any 4-bay NAS would cost at least 200€+ and more for the drives at the time. – DetlevCM – 2015-12-06T21:10:29.537
1A proper server would be more expensive. For a "server PC' I assume redundant power supplies, ECC memory, prope rout of band management. In many cases a proper HW RAID card (a Eur 500-ish). RAID certified nearline SAS drives, .... Linux, BSD or whatever is fine is you know how to manage it. Some home users might. For many buisinesses the cost of a few windows licenses will be less than the cost of training (multiple!) people in it. – Hennes – 2015-12-06T21:21:58.683
It's for home. Not a business style "server", more a "file server", but in fact mainly for backups. Being able to use it as a PC would be a small bonus, but a relatively rare occurrence. – Mawg says reinstate Monica – 2015-12-06T21:45:08.890
@DetlevCM Some good points. I don't want to get into price discussions, but I probably want 4 HDDs so the case alone means that I am unlikely to be able to use a 167€ PC – Mawg says reinstate Monica – 2015-12-06T21:47:14.367
1@Mawg The Dell T20 has 4 3.5" bays as well as space for a slimline CD/DVD etc. drive OR 2 2.5" drives. - An HP Microserver has a similar amount of bays. (Mine has 4 3.5" 3TB drives + 1 2.5" drive) - With a DIY solution it should be possible to add another cage in the future (there is a fair bit of space) – DetlevCM – 2015-12-06T22:18:44.000
1I can treat a NAS as a PC. As already noted, a PC can be a NAS. So your quest to seek a "technical reason" may be unfruitful; the difference between a NAS and a more generalized PC is mainly the focus of the device, not some minor technical boundary that clearly classifies one device as definitely fitting one category. The "why" word, in both of your questions, is what is likely to keep just soliciting opinions. If you have a technical questions where you are looking for the technical reason, try making a new question and asking it. – TOOGAM – 2015-12-06T22:36:11.793
Well, I can't see your Dell T20 at that price, but it does look good and get some good reviews http://www.techradar.com/reviews/pc-mac/peripherals/servers/dell-poweredge-t20-mini-tower-server-1257381/review So I may just look for one on ebay
– Mawg says reinstate Monica – 2015-12-07T08:36:38.2031@Mawg This was back in summer 2014 - A T20 configuration with a G3220 Pentium and 4GB of ECC RAM and no drives could be had for 168€ from various shops. – DetlevCM – 2015-12-07T09:24:12.990