Teresa Carr Deni

Teresa Carr Deni was a Philadelphia Municipal Court judge in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, until she resigned to run for Philadelphia District Attorney in December, 2016.[1]

Deni served on the Board of Revision of Taxes and the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development. She won a retention vote on November 5, 2013, and will serve a six-year term.[2][3][4]

In December 2016 Deni announced that she would be challenging District Attorney of Philadelphia R. Seth Williams in the 2017 Democratic Primary.[1]

Controversy

A 2007 case before Deni involved a 20-year-old prostitute who alleged that she was sexually assaulted by Dominique Gindraw and at least four other men. She agreed to have protected sex with Gindraw for $150 after contacting him through Craigslist.

Upon meeting him, he asked her to also have protected sex with his friend for an additional $100. She reported that when the other man arrived, he threatened her with a gun and demanded that she have unprotected sex with at least three additional men.[5]

After a police report was filed, four men were arrested and charged with rape and assault. Deni dismissed all of the sex and assault charges and instead charged them with armed robbery and theft of services. She justified her decision by stating:

"She consented and she didn't get paid . . . I thought it was a robbery." And that a case like this "minimizes true rape cases and demeans women who are really raped."

The same defendant was charged with a similar crime four days later. However, assistant district attorney Rich DeSipio refused to present the case before Deni owing to her earlier ruling, arguing that "I wouldn't demean her [the victim] that way."[5] Deni threw out the second case for failure to prosecute.

DeSipio has vowed to appeal both rulings.

On October 12, 2007 Deni filed a complaint about DeSipio with the state disciplinary committee. She claimed that it was improper for him to initiate press coverage of the case. Both DeSipio and the reporter he spoke with, Jill Porter, claim that Porter was the one who initiated contact about the case.[6]

Jane Dalton subsequently denounced Deni for her "unforgivable miscarriage of justice" and "clear disregard of the legal definition of rape and the rule of law." Chancellor Jane Dalton commented, "I have personally reviewed the transcript from the defendant's preliminary hearing in this case. Based on my reading, the transcript clearly reflects that the victim decided she was not going to engage in sex with any of the men present, and that she was forced to do so at gunpoint. No one has denied or contradicted this. Judge Deni's belief that because the victim had originally intended to have sex for money and decided not to because she didn't get paid posits that a woman cannot change her mind about having sex, or withdraw her consent to do so, regardless of the circumstances. [...] As Chancellor, a lawyer, and a human being, I am personally offended by this unforgivable miscarriage of justice. The victim has been brutalized twice in this case: first by the assailants, and now by the court."[7]

Notes
  2. "2007 Municipal Election, Tuesday, November 06, 2007, Judge of the Municipal Court: Judicial Retention, 1st Judicial District (Philadelphia County)", Pennsylvania Department of State: Elections Information (website). Accessed November 7, 2007.
  3. Jill Porter. "'Hooker Judge' is not denied... but justice is", Philadelphia Daily News, November 7, 2007.
  4. Warner, Bob (6 November 2013). "Phila. elects 10 Dems to bench - including 4 'not recommended'". Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved 7 November 2013.
  5. Jill Porter (2007-10-12). "Hooker raped and robbed - by justice system?". Philadelphia Daily News.
  6. Jill Porter (2007-10-24). "Move afoot to unseat judge in rape ruling". Philadelphia Daily News.
  7. Jane Dalton (2007-10-30). "Association Chancellor Jane Dalton Issues Statement on Judge Deni's Recent Ruling". Philadelphia Bar Association (website).
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.